“A keel to capture the Cup?” In the summer of 1983, that Boat International headline for Peter Campbell’s article about Australia II must have seemed very optimistic. The New York Yacht Club had bolted down the Auld Mug in a locked cabinet, having jealously guarded the most coveted trophy in sailing for 132 years.
Now we know how prescient that headline would prove, as the ‘Winged Wonder’, the wing-keeled and highly manoeuvrable Australia II would go on to win the 1983 America’s Cup 4-3 from Dennis Conner’s Liberty.
It is surely no coincidence that 1983 was the first occasion of the Louis Vuitton Cup, the elimination series designed to produce a challenger strong enough to overcome the in-built advantages of the defender. That summer in Newport, seven challengers came to do battle, with three of them from Australia - Challenge 12, Advance and Australia II. Canada, France 3 and the Italian Azzurra were there, as was Peter de Savary’s Victory 83 which lost to Australia II in the challenger final.
Some of the old names from that era are still involved today in the 34th America’s Cup. Skipper of France 3, Bruno Troublé, was the man who introduced Louis Vuitton to the world of the America’s Cup, who created the Louis Vuitton Cup and who is still working with the French luxury brand this summer in San Francisco. The helmsman of Advance was a 24-year-old talented skiff sailor from Sydney, and 30 years later Iain Murray is the regatta director of the 34th America’s Cup.
Looking back at 1983, Australia II’s victory really did prove to be the turning point in America’s Cup history. After 132 years of New York Yacht Club impregnability, four winners of the Louis Vuitton Cup have gone on to seize the America’s Cup from the defender. The inception of the Louis Vuitton Cup has helped create a much more balanced contest between the challenger and the defender.
But in 2013, the Louis Vuitton Cup is not in a healthy state. With Artemis Racing still hurriedly completing the assembly of its second AC72 catamaran and its replacement wing rig, there will only be two teams ready for the start of the challenger series in early July - Luna Rossa and Emirates Team New Zealand. In the past 30 years, the cost of mounting an America’s Cup campaign has gone through the roof, and the lack of challengers is a direct and unfortunate result.
And what of all those Australians, three teams of them, who were competing 30 years ago? Well, there may not be a team flying the Southern Cross above its hangar in San Francisco, but the defender - Oracle Team USA - with just one prominent American on its sailing crew, has a great number of Antipodeans, and Australians in particular. James Spithill is the Australian skipper and fellow Sydneysider Grant Simmer is the general manager of the American team. If Simmer helps Oracle to victory this September, it will come exactly thirty Septembers after he navigated Australia II to victory in Newport, Rhode Island, as a 26-year-old rookie.
Another interesting parallel between 1983 and 2013 is the importance of underwater appendages. The winged keel of Australia II was shrouded in mystery, cunningly painted to look like a conventional keel from above the water and carefully skirted to protect from prying eyes whenever the boat was lifted out. This time it is the Kiwis who stole a march on the opposition by devising a way of getting their AC72 to hydrofoil above the water. The unfortunate difference for the Kiwis is that there was no way of hiding their great innovation, and so Oracle has been fast to catch up on foiling technology. Although Emirates Team New Zealand has refused to engage in any line-up with Oracle on San Francisco Bay, the word is that the second-generation Oracle AC72 looks faster than the Kiwi boat. It looks like 2013 is going to be a good year for the defender, although most people assumed the same 30 years ago.
I have barely drawn breath since Oracle’s stunning comeback on San Francisco Bay. A month later, it becomes increasingly clear that the 34th America’s Cup will go down as a classic. A defining moment in the event’s long history. But already for the sailors, the 34th Cup is ancient history as they try to make sense of an uncertain future...
After some ho-hum performances in Europe, I’d begun to wonder if the sailors at Oracle were really that bothered about results on the AC45 circuit. But after a barnstorming performance in Newport, I’ve revised my view. Whichever way you look at it - financial, technological or in pure sailing terms - the Defender is going to be very hard to beat.
After a summer of some of the most high-speed but dull racing the world never wanted to see, the America’s Cup Final delivered some of the most spectacular, unpredictable match racing in the event’s 162-year history. I thought the 2007 final between New Zealand and Alinghi was great. San Francisco 2013 was better.
So all us ‘experts’ observing the America’s Cup have been saying that no one’s ever going to take it away from Oracle next September. But after the defender’s shock pitchpole and subsequent destruction of its multimillion dollar AC72, the odds on a Kiwi victory have shortened considerably.
Nine months in the making was too long, but maybe it was worth the wait. The Protocol for the 35th America’s Cup is not entirely fair, but Team Australia appear to have done a reasonable job in negotiating a decent bargaining position for the prospective challengers who want to compete against Oracle Team USA in summer 2017.
I’ve got my fingers crossed that the Oatleys have more backbone than other recent challengers of record. The wine magnates from downunder are struggling to recruit the top-draw Australians for their fledgling campaign, but they do at least have the power to hold Larry Ellison’s team to the kind of cost-control measures that have long been promised, but which are yet to materialise.
The 34th America’s Cup was great, and all the more so after what was the least competitive, most dull and least well attended Louis Vuitton Cup in its 30 year history. As I wrote three years ago, and three years before that, the last two Challengers of Record have not challenged at all, but rolled over to have their tummies tickled by the Defender. This time we’re hoping the new Challengers of Record, the Oatleys from Australia, will be less poodle and more bulldog.
The two races I witnessed of the Louis Vuitton Cup finals in San Francisco, I was fortunate to see two boats cross the finish line, both intact and still sailing. Until that point, the challenger finals had been a war of attrition, with a nosedive bringing the Kiwis precariously close to capsizing their usually impeccably sailed AC72, Aotearoa.
Changing the rules at the last minute... was it for safety reasons or to gain competitive advantage? In a game where anything goes in the quest for victory, this could be seen as typical Machiavellian fare for the America’s Cup. Trouble is, so soon after the death of Andrew Simpson, quibbling over the merits of ‘rudder elevators’ seems a bit trivial and tasteless.
The death of Andrew ‘Bart’ Simpson has been a huge wake-up call for the organisers of the America’s Cup who have been mounting an eleventh hour review of safety issues, things that should have been discussed and resolved after Oracle’s AC72 capsize last October. All too late for Bart, but let’s hope these safety proposals will avert further fatalities this summer.
This summer we will see an America’s Cup where four giant 72-foot catamarans will barely touch the waters of San Francisco Bay. Instead they’ll be flying around above it, as Swedish team Artemis has recently conceded that ‘foiling’ - rather than floating - is the new way of sailing super fast.
As we reach the business end of this America’s Cup cycle, we find ourselves in the ‘phoney war’ of dissembling and misinformation. Four fast boats on or above the water, yet the news flow has dried to a trickle of Twitter comments. Don’t we, the fans, deserve better? No! This is ‘their’ Cup, and ‘they’ can do what they want.