In handicap racing, the wider you spread
the net, the more meaningless the result becomes. By which I mean that trying
to race an Optimist fairly against a 49er is virtually impossible. If the wind
conditions remain constant throughout the race, then perhaps there is a chance
of getting a fair result. But by and large - whether you're running handicap
races based on corrected time or in a pursuit format - the chances are the wind
will change speed or direction and the best-sailed boat won't necessarily win.
However Y&Y reader Mark Fearnley has
sent me details of an event that sounds like it could genuinely offer an answer
to some - although not all - of the problems listed above, whilst offering a
lot of fun along the way. Here is what Mark had to say: "Dinghy sailing is
neither TV nor spectator friendly. However you may be interested in what
Morecambe and Heysham Yacht Club are doing for the clubs 70th
anniversary regatta in August Bank Holiday this year, as it should be good to
watch as well as compete in.
"The club is to pioneer a new format of
racing - Team pursuit relay racing. Entrants are divided (by the organisers)
into teams of three - with a fast, medium and slow boat in each team. The
organisers will divide entrants up into three-boat teams where the combined
handicaps are as close as possible to the overall average. So a three-boat team
of Topper (PY1290), Laser (PY1078), and 49er (PY747) would be the same as an
Enterprise (PY1116), RS200 (PY1059), and Osprey (PY940) - both totals being
3115.
"Beach start, slowest boats first, in order
of the overall handicap (so the teams above start at the same time - Topper
would start with the Enterprise). There shouldn't be much time between all the
teams starts as they should all be fairly close to the average three-boat
handicap.
"After completion of each lap, the boat
must handover (or throw) the relay batten to the next boat in the team, on the
water, inside a buoyed off ‘change-over' area. This area will be close to the
shore in a bay overlooked by the club slipway - ideal for spectators and TV to
catch the near misses and dropped battens. Short laps close to the shore should
ensure plenty of change-overs, and a good view of who is in the lead at the
allotted finish time.
"As well as being spectator friendly, the
format gets over another perennial problem of handicap racing on tidal waters.
Invariably the faster boats are usually at an advantage as they have no
problems overcoming the tide. This has meant that the usual suspects tend to
win year after year - boring for the slower boats, and discouraging for juniors
and newcomers. Being part of a team of fast, medium, slow boat team makes it
the same for everyone and the team that sails the best, with good handovers
will win."
What a neat idea! Even a non-sailing
spectator might grasp the tortoise-and-hare showdown between the Osprey as it
races to beat the 49er across the finish line. It would be great to see sailing
clubs adopt this format from time to time. The ‘team pursuit relay race', as
Mark calls it, would be a great way of helping sailors to get to know others in
their sailing club, to build some bridges between the junior and senior fleets
for example. Any other clever formats like this, I would love to hear about.
RS600
I bought an RS600 a couple of years ago and
have hardly sailed it since. At the time, when paying £1750 for an old but
perfectly serviceable 600, it seemed like a safe investment but the value of
this stunning singlehander has continued to plummet as old ones like mine are
barely fetching four figures these days.
It is a good fun boat to sail and with a
carbon mast and fully-battened mainsail that goes on forever it is a fast but
pretty low-maintenance piece of hardware. So I must admit to finding the
plummeting secondhand values a bit baffling, although the upside is that it
seems to have become a favourite plaything for students looking for a good
reason to avoid afternoons that probably should be spent in the university
library.
On closer analysis perhaps there are a
number of factors that have thrown the RS600 out of favour. The most obvious
one is that the thrillseekers and have-a-go heroes that initially populated the
class have migrated to the RS700 and Musto Skiff, with the bonus of a gennaker
for added downhill terror. The RS600, with its rounded Laser-like hull form as
opposed to the hard-chined hulls of the 700 and Musto, is also quite a tippy
boat.
The fully-battened mainsail makes the boat
a pig to tack until you get the knack of getting it cleanly through the wind. It
has a tendency to want to stall mid-tack and go head to wind, and once the boat
loses forward motion it can become very unstable, often ending up in a very
unheroic, low-speed capsize. Hence the reason for RS opting to kit out the
RS700 with a semi-battened sail - a much more forgiving sail configuration for
low-speed manoeuvring.
Before buying my own RS600 I borrowed one
for the Nationals a few years ago, and I soon discovered the key to tacking was
to go from close reach to close reach, making sure that you exited the tack
with the bow well off the breeze and the boom well eased from the centreline.
However, my borrowed 600 came with a standard ratchet block and the mainsail
was not going out easily, meaning that I was either stalling the boat or capsizing
it. Day two and I rummaged around in my toolbox for an autoratchet, and went
racing with this instead. The transformation was stunning, I could bear the
boat away out of a tack, the mainsheet would run out and I could keep the boat
on its feet. I've passed on this simple tip to a Musto Skiff friend who was
suffering the same problem and he says it transformed his tacking too. So, one
to try if you haven't already discovered this for yourself.
I have to say, the challenges of sailing
the RS600 are what make it quite appealing to me, but then I'm a bit strange
like that and I guess one of the minority, if the small numbers in the RS600
class are anything to go by.
Contenders
When the RS600 first came along in the
mid-90s, the Contender class saw this as a direct threat to their existence,
and rightfully so you might have thought. And yet numbers in the granddaddy of
trapeze singlehanders are holding up nicely. Class secretary Mark Robinson
reckons the introduction of the carbon rig has contributed to a gentle but
encouraging renaissance in the class. "I'm not sure if it's added much to the
performance of the boat," says Mark, "but the thing I notice most is how much
easier the boat is to bring upright after a capsize." The class website also
points out one of the chief benefits of a carbon boom - that it hurts less when
it whacks you on the head! An experimented best avoided, I'd suggest.
Mark is a self-confessed mid-fleeter who
sails on the Solent out of Gurnard Sailing Club on the Isle of Wight. He sails
against a few other Contenders and some RS700s also based at Gurnard. The two
classes give each other a good run for their money upwind in a breeze, although
of course the RS700 has the legs on the Contender downwind - provided it is
upright! Mark believes the Contender appeals to a broad club-racing audience
because it is that bit less demanding than the modern breed of trapeze
singlehanders.
The hull is heavier, although not
excessively so, and its long waterline and traditionally-battened sail make it
relatively stable and predictable in behaviour. Interestingly, while Kevlar
sails are now permitted they have not necessarily proved any faster. Italian
maestro Andrea Bonnezzi won a windy World Championships in Fremantle recently,
using a standard Dacron mainsail. But then again Tim Holden won a windy
National Championships at Porthpean last year using a Kevlar version.
By Mark Robinson's account, it was an epic
regatta in Porthpean last May. The wind blew consistently over 20 knots and at
times was gusting over 35. While 56 boats entered the Championship, only 48
ventured on to the water. ‘Only 48' is actually very impressive, of course,
because it is hard to imagine many high-performance fleets being able to field
such a high proportion of entrants in winds so severe. It is a testament to the
seaworthiness of the Contender, which sounds like it just gets better and
better the windier it gets.
There are also some impressive class
stalwarts still actively racing, notably Keith Paul who won a few championships
in his younger years in both the Contender and the Flying Dutchman. With Keith
now in his mid-60s, he should be enjoying free bus travel but he is still out
there racing hard in the Contender. As Mark admits: "When Keith Paul sails
through you upwind in 30 knots, it's a sobering moment."
A younger sailor at the Championship, Simon
Mussell, also had a very sobering moment after he fell awkwardly during a
high-speed capsize. It resulted in him breaking his ankle in three places. He
was rushed to hospital to be put back together again, but that was the end of
sailing for the summer. In fact it was nearly the end of his boat, as the
strong winds were giving the rescue cover more than enough to do just worrying
about people, let alone hardware. So while Simon was being driven to hospital,
his upturned Contender was being blown downwind for some miles down the Cornish
coast.
Help came in the form of Matt Aston who,
having stepped ashore from a knackering day at the races and hearing of Simon's
plight, immediately jumped into a Porthpean SC rescue boat to help find the
missing Contender. Having found the upturned hull many miles to leeward and in
some danger of being trashed on the rocks, Matt righted the boat and sailed it
back to Porthpean. Mark Robinson says Matt is just the sort of guy every class
needs. "He's a real doer and a shaker. He makes things happen. It was a
particularly cold and wet day in May, but he didn't think twice about doing
what he did."
Simon Mussell's story doesn't end here,
however. Having missed the summer season while his ankle was healing up, he
returned to the class at the Weston open meeting in September and promptly won
the event. He then went to Fremantle where he finished top Brit in fourth
place, his best ever result. Mark says: "Simon did a great job of getting back
on the bike. He said that after his injury he felt a little tentative sailing
down the windy reaches, but he wonders if that even helped him get a better
result."