With 176 entries, one of the outstanding
successes of the dinghy racing season was the Fireball World Championships in
Teignmouth. I spoke to Steve Chesney, chairman of the organising committee for
the event, to find out some of the secrets of the Fireball's success. One thing
that came up early in the conversation was that the class committee have made a
conscious bid to put the wants and needs of the middle-order and
back-of-the-fleet sailors before the high-fliers at the top end.
"The class has focused on its core
membership rather than the leading lights of the fleet," was Steve Chesney's
way of putting it. "We've focused on this theme of inclusion, making sure that
everyone feels they're getting something out of the class." It sounds so
obvious when you have it spelt out like that, to serve the needs of your
biggest audience. And yet how many class associations are run from the top
down? The vast majority, I would hazard a guess. Because the people at the top
end of the fleet are the more accomplished sailors, they are seen as the
opinion leaders and trend formers, and they tend to end up making up the bulk
of the committee. And then the committee puts itself in danger of becoming
self-serving, thinking of the needs of the top flight rather than ways of
nurturing the fleet as a whole.
This is not a criticism of the people
involved. It is a largely thankless task being part of a sailing committee, and
the only people who have a right to criticise their class committees are those
that are prepared to do more themselves. But one of the problems with the way
classes are run is that their annual general meetings tend to be held during the
National Championships. From one point of view, this makes absolute sense,
because nowhere do you get a greater gathering of numbers than at the
Nationals. But it can also be a very elitist gathering, with the huge numbers
of club sailors and ‘Swallows and Amazons' potterers very under-represented at
a racing championship. And so there is little drive to attract new blood to a
championship, because the AGM becomes a self-serving event for those already
signed up to the racing cause.
Steve Chesney has been a keen Fireball
sailor for 20 years now, and when he first got involved it was still a very
top-driven class. But in the late 80s there was a move "to drill down into the membership",
and find out what the whole fleet wanted. Bear in mind that 20 years ago, the
Fireball was one of the primary battlegrounds for boatbuilders, mast
manufacturers and sailmakers to assert their names. Just about every major
sailmaker had at least one jockey in the fleet, with the aim of winning the
Nationals or Worlds, and selling lots of sails off the back of that success. So
there was a lot of buzz in the class, but it could be quite an intimidating
place to be for the middle-of-the-fleet sailors. And I should know, because I
was one of them.
Then the big plastic-boat revolution of the
1990s came along, and the Fireball looked under some threat from boats like the
Iso and RS400. But the Fireball responded well to the challenge. The
construction rules were still written around the boat's original concept as a
home-built kit boat, but by the 80s nearly everyone was buying
professionally-built boats. And one of the rules of the class said that the
sides of the cockpit had to rise vertically from the floor. This made it very
difficult for builders to construct plastic Fireballs that could be popped out
of a mould.
So the class decided to rewrite the rules
and permit a slight slope in the cockpit sides. This had no effect whatsoever
on the handling or performance of the boat but it meant the cockpit could be
moulded in one piece. This one rule change meant that professional builders
could reduce building costs by up to £1,500.
The Fireball class was also an early
instigator of the Gold, Silver and Bronze fleet divisions, a concept that many
other classes have since adopted. In 49er international events, for example, fleet
sizes are limited to 25, so the race to qualify for the top 25 of Gold is
absolutely crucial. If you miss the cut at the end of the qualifying series,
then the best you can hope to finish after that is 26th overall if
you end up in Silver, or 51st if you end up in Bronze. There is no
consolation prize for ending up in these divisions, and quite often you get
made to feel like second-class citizens as Gold fleet racing tends to take
precedence when time or wind are in short supply to the race officer.
In an Olympic class, this elitist approach
is understandable, but it is an approach that non-elitist, amateur classes can
ill afford to follow. This is where the Fireball class has scored so highly.
Steve Chesney says you can't afford to pay lip service to the scheme, and the
Fireballs have gone out of their way to make the Silver and Bronze fleets seems
like mini-championships in their own right. "All the best prizes go to sailors
in the Silver and Bronze fleets," explains Steve. "The Gold fleet winners get
the trophies, but the big prizes like drysuits, wetsuits or new sails go to
people further down the fleet. It's also quite a badly kept secret that some
names get overlooked when we're pulling ‘random' names out of the hat for spot
prizes!" The aim is that by the end of the week, everyone at least feels they
could have come away with something, even if it didn't happen that particular
week.
The other thing the Fireballs do
differently is by using a subjective committee-based process of dividing
sailors into Gold, Silver or Bronze. "I suppose you could call it a
Wimbledon-style seeding, where the divisions are decided by a bunch of people
sitting around talking about it," says Steve. So if some ‘unknown' sailor turns
up, never having raced a Fireball before, called Brotherton or Carveth for
example, then he won't automatically be put into the Bronze fleet.
Another thing that has gained popularity in
a number of classes, but with mixed results, is the buddy system where a
top-of-the-fleet sailor is paired off with a mid-to-back-of-the-fleet sailor.
This is a great idea for sharing information, tuning tips and encouragement
around the fleet, but can easily wane if sailors don't put enough energy into
it. So the Fireballs have a social evening where the beer is free - provided
you turn up with your buddy. Now there's an incentive to inspire you to share those
top tuning secrets.
Steve says the inspiration for such great
ideas comes not from one individual, but from a very energetic and committed
class committee. The loyalty of so many Fireball sailors to the class bears
testament to just how successful they have become. Steve's 20-year love affair
with the Fireball is by no means unique. Vyv Townend, my old school mate who
won the recent Worlds crewing for Chips Howarth, has been sailing Fireballs for
more than 20 years too. I bumped into Jim Turner at the recent America's Cup
Act in Sweden, where Jim was doing his grinding for the French K-Challenge, and
he asked me to pass on his congratulations to Vyv. Through gritted teeth, I
should point out, as Jim and a couple of other sailors have been superseded as
the most successful Fireball crews ever, their two World Championship victories
now being eclipsed by Vyv's three wins.
So what keeps people like Vyv and Steve in
one spot for so long? Steve says being part of the Fireballs is like having an
extended family that spreads around the world, to Australia, the Americas,
continental Europe and parts of Africa. "We stay in each others' houses, we
send each other Christmas cards," says Steve. But it is also about the boat.
Back in those ‘dark days' of the early 90s, when the boom of new boats arrived
on the scene, Steve says he always felt optimistic about the Fireball's future.
"We were always confident that the design of the boat would see her through,
because of her ease of sailing, and low all-up weight. On the water we felt it
would always sell itself very well, because it was a boat built for sailors."
Aren't all sailing boats built for sailors, I queried? Steve counters that the
Fireball was never designed as a ‘product' in the modern sense, but simply as a
boat for sailors.
Steve points out that at less than 80kg,
the Fireball is still a light boat even by modern standards. "The hull weight
is around 30 per cent less than the Iso, I believe." Steve also reckons the
Fireball is easier to sail than most modern classes. "It's flat-bottomed, it's
got big chines, with rails on the bottom which all make it incredibly stable.
Any numpty can sail a Fireball...." By comparison, some of the double-bottomed
plastic boats of the modern era are less stable, and many are less well-behaved.
I was never a fan of the Iso in its
original form, with that horrible kick-up rudder borrowed from a catamaran. I
haven't tried the Iso in its more modern form, so I'm not in a position to
judge it now, but I raced in the first Nationals and it was not a particularly
pleasant boat to sail. But I was still a fan. It was a revolutionary boat. Suddenly,
for around £4,000 you could race other moderately high-performance boats on
equal terms. This was for about half the price of a Fireball, and with none of
the associated arms race of the Fireball that existed then, whether it was
selecting the right hull shape, mast or sail combination. Or being the wrong
weight, because it should be remembered that what gave the Iso its name was in its
pioneering use of weight equalisation, using those trademark plug-in wings.
The Fireball was shaken out of its complacency
and duly responded with smart ideas such as the cockpit change that made the
boat cheaper to produce. I'm sure the professional approach of the class
association and the clever ways it has encouraged more sailors into the fold
owes some debt of thanks to the Iso, which itself was dreamed up by a former
Fireball World Champion John Caig. I call it the Ryanair effect. I may not be a
fan of driving up to Stansted and then racing in a stampede across the tarmac
against my fellow passengers for the best seat on the plane. But I appreciate Ryanair's
cheap prices and the fact that they jolted British Airways and the older
airlines out of their overpriced ways. Ryanair has made the airline market
better for everybody, and so has the Iso in the world of dinghy sailing.
These days, the Fireball is much more
one-design than it was, with Winder Boats providing a standard package that is
good enough to win the Worlds straight out of the box, along with some less
common options such as the Swiss Duvoisin hull, for those still looking for
something slightly different. I should allow Steve Chesney to finish what he
was saying, before his fellow Fireballers take offence at what he was saying
earlier. As he pointed out: "Any numpty can sail a Fireball," but what he also went
on to say before I interrupted him, was: "It's also incredibly difficult to get
the best out of it. If you take a wave badly, for example, you get punished. So
there is a challenge there for everyone, from the least experienced to the
best."
The easy-to-sail-but-difficult-to-sail-well
concept brings to mind the Optimist and I say as much to Steve, at the same
time fearing he might hit me for comparing his beloved high-performance trapeze
boat to a seven-foot box. "No, I think the comparison to the Optimist is
perfect. One of the things we like about the Fireball is you can take it out in
virtually any weather. But I remember one particularly windy day at Carnac [in
northern France], and just as we were coming in battered and bruised thinking
enough was enough, a bunch of kids in their Oppies were just going out." And
for that, and many other good reasons, I'm sure we'll be talking fondly about
these floating boxes for years to come.